Chimerism: not being yourself has medical implications

Science has demolished another idea that researchers once knew to be "true" about genes, the chains of molecules that encode the blueprint for the human body. The consensus a few years back was that every cell in each person's body has the same genetic signature, the same set of DNA unique to that person. It is a pretty important concept if you think about it.

Researchers determine things like paternity, genetic risk for disease and presence at crime scenes by examining just a few of the trillion cells in each a person.This practice is based on the assumption that the few cells taken accurately represent the genes in the rest of that individual.

But what if one person had different sets of genes, or genomes, in different cells? Some people, it turns out, have patches of cells with genetic changes in them not found in other parts of their bodies. Some have cells with genes that came from other people.

Such variety is called chimerism or mosaicism, depending on the details, both of which were the subject of a recent article by writer Carl Zimmer in the New York Times. We used the occasion of the article to ask Bruce Korf, M.D., Ph.D., chair of the UAB Department of Genetics, for his thoughts on the implications of these ideas for medicine. 

Show notes for the conference: 

0:35 To recap, the blueprint for the human body is encoded in genes, many of which hold the information necessary for the building of one or more proteins. Gene expression is the process by which information stored in genes is converted into proteins, the workhorse molecules that make up the body’s structures and carry its signals.

1:38 The dogma for decades in genetics was that all cells in one person, having all come from the same original cell (the embryo), had copies of the same genetic material throughout life. That belief was correct to a point, but did not tell the whole story, said Dr. Korf. Each person does indeed have a unique genome, a set of genetic material made up of about 3 billion bases, the “letters” that make up the DNA code, but changes in that code occur every time anyone our trillions of cells divides and multiplies. So mutations are underway constantly, with different changes building up in different groups of cells. Furthermore, several events, some of them more common that once thought, can inject other people's cells into our bodies.

6:35 Chimerism is the presence of two or more genetically different cells occurring in the same body. While we are taught the a fetus results when one sperm fertilizes one egg, more pregnanices than once thought may result from multiple fertilization events. More than one sperm fertilizes more than one egg in the womb get mixed to form one body. Beyond the number of twins born, researchers now suspect that many single baby pregnancies started as twins. One of the embryos then died early on, but not before sharing blood and cells with its twin. Thus you have one baby with the genomes of two babies mixed together. In other cases, two fertilized eggs may fuse together with no evidence they were once two individuals. Obviously, people who get an organ transplant are chimeras as well, as are most mothers, who absorbed their some of their babies' cells while pregnant.

8:15 Chimerism, which happens during conception, is different from the changes in genes that arise from constant small changes in genetic code underway in every human cell over a person's lifetime, a concept called mosaicism. Most of us have patches of cells in our body that have different genes than patches growing elsewhere. While the overall differences are small, mounting evidence suggests they may be meaningful. In the UAB Medical Genomics lab led by Dr. Korf,  the team studies many genetic orders that proceed from mosaicism. In many cases, a patient will have a genetic change that has caused cancer just in one patch of skin, instead of a change across the entire body.

11:06  When a person has two sets of different DNA in their cells, one set will greatly predominate with the other in relatively few cells. Until recently, DNA technologies often could not capture the less frequently occurring genome, losing it in the vast background of the majority. Next-generation sequencing technologies, however, can now identify rare cells that have a different genotype than most of the cells in a person, a capability which may explain why this topic has been more in the news lately. According to the Times article, recent cases have featured genetic test results that found a mother was not the mother of one of her children, and that a sexual assault suspect did not have the same genetic signature in his sperm as in his saliva. The fact both were chimeras threw the tests off.

12:56 While we don't yet know whether cells with different DNA have a big impact on say hearth disease risk, they are known to have a profound role in cancer. Whether the DNA is atypical from chimerism or mosaicism, it is possible the change may affect a cell's ability to divide and multiply, perhaps leading to abnormal growth. Cancer is a disease of mosaicism, said Dr. Korf, because a cell comes to include a small changes in its DNA that remove normal growth limits to create tumors.

16:45  We don't really know how many different genomes we have in the cells in our body. If you look at it one way, we have as many different sets of genetic material as we have cells, since small, unique and random changes slip in as each cell divides and multiplies into two more. Most of the changes have no impact on healthy function, but some do, and the trick is to pick out trillions the few that do.

17:22  Cells with slightly different DNA sequences obviously play a role in cancer, but the remaining question is whether or not small numbers of cells with differing genomes different play a role in other major diseases, like heart disease or Alzheimer's. Is it possible that chimerism or mosaicism in the heart can cause rhythm disorders or that such changes in the pancreas bring about diabetes?